Lindsay Lohan, Rachel McAdams ” in ‘Imply Ladies’ Sequel (Supply)

Are Cady and Regina revisiting their Plastics roots?

A supply tells PEOPLE that each Lindsay Lohan and Rachel McAdams — who performed Cady Heron and Regina George, respectively, within the unique Imply Ladies — can be open to creating a sequel to the 2004 teen comedy, which was written by Tina Fey and directed by Mark Waters.

The movie supply says Lohan, 37, “desires to do one other [Mean Girls] and has a very good relationship together with her former solid members,” which additionally embrace Amanda Seyfried and Lacey Chabert. “They’re her pals and have been. One other movie can be nice for her and for audiences who liked the unique.”

As for McAdams, 45, the supply tells PEOPLE the latest Tony nominee “would possible do a Imply Ladies sequel if all the things introduced to her made sense,” regardless of her not collaborating within the reunion with Lohan, Seyfried, 38, and Chabert, 41, for a Walmart advert final fall.

“She has no regrets about not doing a Walmart industrial, which is a special factor,” the souce provides of McAdams. “She is tremendous busy, however likes her former solid members and can be interested by speaking a few sequel if it turns into a actuality.”

Reps for Lohan and McAdams didn’t instantly reply to PEOPLE’s requests for remark.

By no means miss a narrative — join PEOPLE’s free each day publication to remain up-to-date on the most effective of what PEOPLE has to supply, from juicy superstar information to driving human-interest tales.

A lot of the unique Imply Ladies solid has opened up a few potential sequel through the years. In December 2022, Lohan and Seyfried reunited throughout a chat for Interview journal, through which they mentioned the prospects of one other film.

“A Imply Ladies 2 isn’t going to occur, is it?” stated Seyfried, including later, “Pay attention, we’re all a part of one another’s worlds whether or not we prefer it or not, and it’s very nice to keep in touch as adults.”

“Yeah, everybody’s nonetheless the identical,” Lohan agreed. “It is enjoyable to have sure reminiscences that we will not share with anybody else.”

McAdams starred as queen bee Regina, with Seyfried and Chabert because the Plastics, the group of fashionable women at school who’re ultimately infiltrated and brought down by Lohan’s new child Cady — however not earlier than she loses herself within the quick tempo of high-school politics.

“It could be enjoyable to play Regina George later in her life and see the place life took her!” McAdams replied after she was requested a few sequel to Imply Ladies throughout a Heroes of Well being: COVID-19 livestream again in April 2020, in response to Yahoo Leisure.

Lohan beforehand revisited the Imply Ladies universe as Cady in a buzzy Walmart industrial final November, alongside the unique movie’s fellow solid members Seyfried, Chabert, Rajiv Surendra and Daniel Franzese.

Imply Ladies has amassed an enormous following since its premiere 20 years in the past, although has by no means had an official theatrical sequel (a 2011 follow-up premiered on ABC Household with a wholly new solid save for Tim Meadows, who reprised his function as Principal Duvall).

Requested on the New York Metropolis premiere of the Imply Ladies film musical — through which Lohan makes a shock cameo because the Mathletes competitors moderator — a few potential Imply Ladies 2, Franzese, 45, informed PEOPLE that the unique solid “are all down” to do extra.

“You bought to inform the boss girl over there,” he stated in the course of the January occasion, referring to Fey, 53. “I am positive [she’s] heard it 1,000,000 occasions, however she’s the gatekeeper, so we’re all ready.”

Imply Ladies (2004) is accessible to stream on Paramount+ and Apple TV+.