Highlight PA is an impartial, nonpartisan, and nonprofit newsroom producing investigative and public-service journalism that holds energy to account and drives constructive change in Pennsylvania. Join our free newsletters.
HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro is being eyed as a possible Democratic vice presidential nominee, however with that spotlight has come intense scrutiny of his help for a historically conservative thought: taxpayer-funded non-public faculty vouchers.
Since taking workplace final yr, Shapiro has change into probably the most distinguished Democratic voice within the state for such a program. Final summer time, he backed a controversial Republican voucher proposal to the chagrin of longtime occasion allies and influential unions that supported his candidacy — although he finally vetoed the language after going through opposition from fellow Democrats.
Regardless of his high-profile public backing, Shapiro’s embrace of vouchers seems to be a comparatively new conviction, based on political insiders and others who’ve labored with and adopted the governor in his two-decade political profession. As a state lawmaker within the 2000s, he didn’t advocate for the problem, they recalled, not to mention push laws.
Shapiro’s pondering on the problem may be understood partially via his relationship with at the very least one distinguished faculty selection advocate, sources advised Highlight PA.
Voucher packages fluctuate broadly, however they broadly route public cash to pay for tuition at non-public and spiritual faculties.
Proponents argue they provide youngsters attending struggling public faculties essential choices, whereas opponents say they weaken public faculties by diverting funding and don’t essentially assist college students. Research have proven that their results are blended, with newer evaluations of statewide packages displaying they’ve induced pupil take a look at scores to say no.
Shapiro didn’t publicly again making a voucher program till his run for governor in 2022, based on a overview of reports articles and public statements he has made.
He has tempered his place — deeply unpopular amongst lots of his Democratic colleagues — by saying he’ll solely help such a program if it doesn’t take cash away from public schooling.
“I believe it’s essential that we absolutely fund public schooling,” Shapiro advised reporters at a 2022 marketing campaign occasion. “And I additionally suppose it’s actually essential that we empower mother and father to place their children in one of the best place for them to have the ability to succeed.”
To make sure, throughout his time as governor, each state budgets have included main public schooling investments. This yr’s $1.1 billion improve for Okay-12 schooling was the most important single-year bump within the state’s historical past, based on Shapiro.
“In his time in workplace, Governor Shapiro has persistently delivered historic will increase in public schooling funding and eventually, after a long time of inaction, moved Pennsylvania in direction of adequately and equitably funding our public faculties,” Shapiro spokesperson Manuel Bonder mentioned in an announcement to Highlight PA.
Behind the scenes, nevertheless, he has additionally tried to persuade fellow Democrats to put aside public {dollars} for vouchers. For a lot of of them, Shapiro’s insistence on the problem is confounding.
Shapiro, 51, has been an elected official since 2005, when he joined the state Home representing the Montgomery County district the place he grew up and nonetheless lives. A number of former colleagues say that in his eight years within the chamber, he wasn’t concerned in class selection debates in any vital approach.
“I’ve had conversations with [Shapiro] about many different issues,” mentioned Tony Payton, a former Democratic state consultant from Philadelphia who helps faculty vouchers and served alongside the governor, “and that wasn’t one in every of them.”
There would have been alternatives.
In 2011, whereas Shapiro was nonetheless a state Home member, Gov. Tom Corbett, a Republican, launched a push to create a college voucher program. That effort handed the state Senate with bipartisan backing however foundered within the state Home, the place it by no means got here up for a vote.
State Sen. Anthony Williams, a Philadelphia Democrat, was one of many Democrats who supported it. He advised Highlight PA that Shapiro wasn’t concerned in pushing for this system.
“Any Democrat that was for college selection, I’d know that,” he mentioned.
Williams, who continues to be a member of the chamber and stays one of many Democratic Social gathering’s strongest faculty selection supporters within the state, says he didn’t get a touch that Shapiro was open to vouchers till he was working for governor.
“Now, I don’t know the entire motivation,” Williams mentioned. He added that when he spoke to Shapiro about passing faculty selection laws extra not too long ago, the governor mentioned it was the “proper factor to do.”
Williams added that Shapiro “has buddies who’re within the faculty selection neighborhood who align with him about that situation. And so within the conversations, I’m advised, this situation got here up, they usually form of discovered widespread floor.”
These buddies, Williams mentioned, “had been supporters, who’re robust selection folks, who supported his marketing campaign, as a result of they had been supportive of the problem of selection.”
Three sources who spoke on situation of anonymity to debate a delicate political situation advised Highlight PA that notable amongst them is Joel Greenberg, a billionaire co-founder of the worldwide high-speed buying and selling agency Susquehanna Worldwide Group.
Greenberg served on Shapiro’s gubernatorial transition group with an task to concentrate on schooling coverage, and a number of sources confirmed to Highlight PA that the 2 have identified one another for greater than a decade.
In 2015, Shapiro, then a Montgomery County commissioner, gave the Philadelphia Inquirer his evaluation of Greenberg’s political and philanthropic work.
“He’s a serious employer within the area and he’s splendidly philanthropic — for Jewish causes, instructional causes and different neighborhood organizations,” Shapiro advised the paper.
One other co-founder of Susquehanna Worldwide Group is much more well-known on the earth of Pennsylvania faculty selection advocacy: billionaire Wall Road dealer Jeffrey Yass. He’s emerged as a serious Republican donor nationally and an inescapable energy dealer inside the commonwealth, regardless of his almost nonexistent public profile.
Each Greenberg and Yass have been concerned in bankrolling the varsity selection motion for greater than a decade in Pennsylvania.
“We’re not on this to run constitution faculties, to handle constitution faculties. That is purely altruistic,” Greenberg advised WHYY in 2015, when requested about his help for Williams’ mayoral marketing campaign. “We view this as serving to children have a selection who’re trapped in failing, oftentimes violent faculties.”
Together with fellow suburban Philadelphia billionaire and SIG co-founder Arthur Dantchik, Greenberg and Yass had been at one level the primary donors to College students First, a political motion committee based in 2010 to help faculty selection candidates.
Shapiro accepted $175,000 from that PAC between 2012 and 2016, based on marketing campaign finance data. Throughout that point, he was a Montgomery County commissioner and, by 2016, was working for legal professional common.
The donations to Shapiro’s legal professional common marketing campaign so troubled Philadelphia’s lecturers union that it quietly pulled its endorsement on the final minute, a number of information retailers reported.
The union declined to remark on the time, however a supply with information of the state of affairs confirmed to Highlight PA that the union pulled its endorsement over the College students First donations. (The Pennsylvania State Schooling Affiliation, a bigger, statewide lecturers union, continued to again Shapiro in that election.)
Throughout the 2022 gubernatorial race, PACs related to Yass spent hundreds of thousands through the main to oppose eventual Republican nominee state Sen. Doug Mastriano. A type of PACs, Commonwealth Leaders Fund, ran anti-Shapiro advertisements through the common election however scaled again then stopped that spending shortly after Shapiro publicly pledged his help for vouchers.
As soon as elected, Shapiro sought to create such a program as a part of the 2023-24 state funds.
“I imagine each youngster of God deserves a shot right here within the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, and among the finest methods we are able to assure their success is ensuring each youngster has a top quality schooling,” Shapiro advised Fox Information in June 2023, late within the state’s funds course of.
The remarks preceded the Republican-controlled state Senate’s sudden passage of a funds deal that included $100 million in taxpayer cash to fund non-public faculty tuition for college kids in low-performing public districts.
However as soon as the funds reached the state Home, Shapiro acquired arduous pushback from the decrease chamber’s new Democratic majority. In a politically embarrassing setback, Shapiro agreed to veto the voucher {dollars} in alternate for the remainder of the plan’s passage. That veto led to an almost six-month funds deadlock as state Senate Republicans claimed betrayal.
In his February funds handle this yr, Shapiro known as on the legislature to once more think about vouchers, although a high Republican chief later accused him of being unwilling to make use of his “bully pulpit” to get such a program throughout the end line.
His ongoing help additionally hasn’t saved him from Yass-funded criticism.
For the previous two years, a 501(c)(4) nonprofit, which doesn’t need to disclose its donors, has spent prodigiously on advertisements and different lobbying to criticize politicians who don’t help vouchers.
The group, Commonwealth Motion, has acquired vital {dollars} from the free market Commonwealth Companions Chamber of Entrepreneurs, based on that group’s most up-to-date filings to the IRS. Commonwealth Companions runs two political motion committees which might be among the many most lively in Pennsylvania faculty selection advocacy, and each are nearly totally funded by Yass.
Between April 2023 and March 2024 — the final recorded submitting — Commonwealth Motion reported spending greater than $973,000 on oblique schooling lobbying, which incorporates promoting and different strategies aimed toward shifting public opinion.
One video from final summer time funded by Commonwealth Motion accused Shapiro of “selecting particular pursuits over children.”
Commonwealth Motion is linked to a longtime conservative group in Pennsylvania, the Commonwealth Basis. Since summer time 2023, the outside of the group’s Harrisburg constructing, which is throughout the road from the state Capitol, has featured advertisements calling for Shapiro to move the voucher plan. The muse is now funding a six-figure newspaper and TV advert marketing campaign.
“You lied, and also you turned your again on us once more,” Printess Garrett, a Harrisburg mom, says in a TV spot. “The one factor now we have for our kids is our phrase, and if we are able to’t belief in your phrase, we don’t have the rest.”
Shifting ahead, political sources advised Highlight PA they anticipate lecturers unions and different public schooling advocates to be among the many most skeptical of a Shapiro vice presidency.
On Wednesday, 28 schooling advocacy teams from throughout the nation despatched an open letter to presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Kamala Harris arguing that “it’s important that our President and Vice President be wholly dedicated to our nation’s public schooling system and keen to struggle towards faculty privatization in all its kinds.”
However to Payton, not contemplating Shapiro for backing a coverage to assist mother and father within the hunt for what’s finest for his or her children is a nasty selection.
“To blatantly disqualify anyone over one thing ideological like that’s silly,” Payton mentioned.
