Anne Banfield left West Virginia in early 2022 and is now an OB-GYN in Maryland.
Amanda Andrade-Rhoades for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Amanda Andrade-Rhoades for NPR
When the Supreme Court docket overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022, states scrambled to enact their very own authorized insurance policies to manage abortion, and a patchwork sample emerged throughout the nation. Whereas some states protected and even expanded abortion rights and entry, others severely curtailed it — like West Virginia.
“West Virginia has at all times had areas which have been deserts in different types of well being care,” says Dr. Anne Banfield, an OB-GYN who offers abortion providers and left the state in early 2022. “And so these ladies actually, in that state, or anybody who wants full-service reproductive care, usually should journey huge distances, creating these deserts, as we name them, the place providers simply aren’t accessible.”
Now, Banfield is worried about what the 2024 election might carry, and what new modifications or restrictions might come.
“I used to be, I assume, very naive,” Banfield advised NPR about her mindset for years earlier than leaving West Virginia. “It by no means crossed my thoughts then that I’d ever stay in a post-Roe world.”
Subsequent-door states with vastly completely different insurance policies
When the Dobbs choice prevailed, West Virginia’s state legislature acted rapidly to make abortion unlawful with only a few exceptions. The story in neighboring Maryland was completely different. Sensing that Roe was at risk, Maryland state legislators launched quite a lot of payments in early 2022 to guard abortion rights. One invoice that handed shall be up for a referendum vote this fall, and Maryland voters will resolve whether or not or to not enshrine abortion rights in an modification to their state structure.
Banfield now practices in a rural space of southern Maryland, and stated she doesn’t have the identical considerations about being an abortion supplier as she had in West Virginia, nor does she really feel the identical sort of stress she beforehand felt to interact in political activism across the concern.
“In Maryland, sure, there are nonetheless issues, in fact, that as an OB-GYN will not be issues I’d assist which might be launched into the legislature,” she stated. However she added that these points “are way more few and much between” in comparison with West Virginia.
Banfield is now waiting for the 2024 election and past.
Amanda Andrade-Rhoades for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Amanda Andrade-Rhoades for NPR
Nonetheless, Banfield stated she had a minimum of come to worth her relationship with the group in Elkins, Wv. whereas she was there. She stated she by no means acquired any sort of abuse or threats that some suppliers face, and credit that, partly, to the truth that her former clinic solely supplied medically-necessary abortions, and never so-called elective procedures.
“When you hear a narrative locally as a result of any individual’s cousin or sister, they’ll let you know the half about, ‘Oh, it was horrible, the newborn had no mind,’ or… ‘her water had damaged and she or he acquired sick,’” Banfield stated of the reactions she would hear. However in a state the place a majority of residents in years previous have stated abortions needs to be unlawful in virtually all instances, Banfield stated there was a restrict to a few of her neighbors’ understanding.
“You do not essentially hear different tales … like, ‘The affected person had 4 different youngsters. She was on two types of contraception and acquired pregnant and knew she could not afford to have one other child,’” Banfield stated. “Effectively, perhaps you do not contemplate {that a} good purpose for an abortion, however it certain as hell is for any individual else.”
Fascinated by what 2024 and past might carry
Banfield says she nonetheless has many associates in Elkins, and just lately attended commencement for her god-daughter there. She isn’t certain she would have left the state based mostly on the Dobbs choice alone, however that training in Maryland means she and her sufferers have extra assets and choices to make one of the best choice for his or her well being. And whereas she is pretty assured within the state of abortion rights in Maryland, she is worried about what might occur on the federal degree.
“My larger concern for Maryland could be if there could be a federal [anti-abortion] invoice handed. After which clearly we’re all caught in the identical boat,” she stated.
As Banfield appears to be like forward to November, she is discouraged by one other Biden-Trump rematch. And regardless of President Joe Biden’s promise to guard abortion entry, and former President Donald Trump’s pledge to go away the problem as much as particular person states, Banfield says there are different unknowns that fear her.
“One of many issues that Maryland had carried out was to place in place a protect regulation to attempt to defend suppliers right here in Maryland from the results of legal guidelines in states which have restrictions,” she defined. “However we do not know that when certainly one of us flies into the state of Texas, might your title be on a listing? We do not know that these restrictive states aren’t going to attempt to do extra issues to stop sufferers from touring to achieve care.”
Nonetheless, Banfield urges voters to concentrate to their native and state candidates as a lot because the presidential election. The Home and the Senate, she stated, are those who would both ship a federal abortion invoice to the president’s desk, or kill it earlier than it even acquired there.
“Please exit and vote in your native elected officers and in your senators and in your legislators,” she stated. “As a result of they make such a distinction in what occurs and what really goes to the president’s desk.”
